Last updated: [DATE OF PUBLICATION]
Zuddies is built around discussion, and the comments are part of that. These guidelines explain what makes a good comment here, what we remove and how moderation works. By commenting, you agree to follow them.
The short version
- Argue with the point, not the person.
- Don’t post anything about a real person that you couldn’t back up.
- Keep other people’s private details private.
- Stay on topic, and don’t use the comments to advertise.
What we welcome
- Disagreement. You can challenge the article, the writer, other commenters and Zuddies itself. Strong views are fine when they are put civilly.
- Experience and knowledge. If you know the area, the trade or the people involved, tell us what you know and how you know it.
- Sources. Links that back up a point are useful. Please say what the link shows rather than just posting it.
- Corrections. If you spot an error in an article, say so. To make sure an editor sees it, also use our correction request form.
What we remove
Personal attacks and abuse
Insults, name-calling, threats, intimidation and harassment of the writer or other commenters. That includes following someone from thread to thread.
Hate
Attacks on people because of their gender, civil or family status, sexual orientation, religion, age, disability, race, colour, nationality, ethnic origin or membership of the Traveller community. Slurs are removed whatever the context.
Damaging claims about real people
Accusing a named or identifiable person of a crime, dishonesty or other wrongdoing without evidence, or repeating rumours about them. This applies to public figures as well as private individuals. Comments like this can be defamatory, and both you and Zuddies can be held responsible for them.
Comments that could affect a court case
Speculating about the guilt or innocence of someone facing a criminal trial, or naming anyone the courts have said must not be named, such as victims of sexual offences and children in court proceedings. Comments like this can be contempt of court.
Private information
Home addresses, phone numbers, private email addresses, workplaces, car registrations or photos of other people, or anything that would identify someone who hasn’t chosen to be public. This includes your own details. Please don’t post them where anyone can see them.
Spam and advertising
Promoting a business, product, channel or fundraiser, repeated copy-and-paste comments and links that don’t add to the discussion. Comments with more than two links are held for review automatically.
Pretending to be someone else
You can comment under a nickname, but not under the name of a real person, organisation or Zuddies staff member, and not under several names to make a view look more popular.
Anything else unlawful
Content that is illegal in Ireland, encourages violence or self-harm, or infringes someone else’s copyright, such as pasting in a full article from another site.
Off-topic and deliberately false comments
Comments that have nothing to do with the article, or that present things the writer knows are false as fact, particularly about health, safety or elections.
Mild swearing in passing is fine. Swearing aimed at a person isn’t.
How moderation works
- Spam filter. Every comment is checked by an automatic spam filter before it appears.
- Your first comment. The first time you comment, an editor approves it before it appears. After that, your comments appear straight away, as long as you use the same name and email address.
- Review. Editors read comments regularly and act on reports. We may remove a comment at any time if it breaks these guidelines.
- Removal, not editing. We don’t edit what you wrote. If part of a comment breaks the rules, we remove the whole comment. Replies that only make sense alongside it may go too.
- Repeat breaches. If someone keeps breaking the rules, we may hold all their comments for review or block them from commenting.
- Closing. Comments close 30 days after an article is published, and sometimes sooner on stories that attract abuse or touch on court cases. Existing comments stay up.
Moderation decisions are made by Zuddies editors. We try to be consistent and fair, but we won’t always explain individual decisions in public.
Reporting a comment
If you see a comment that breaks these guidelines, email [GENERAL EMAIL] with a link to the article, the name shown on the comment and what the problem is. We will look at it as soon as we can. If a comment is about you and you think it is untrue or unlawful, say so in your email and we will treat it as a priority.
To ask about one of your own comments that was removed, email the same address.
Your comments and your information
You are responsible for what you post. You keep ownership of your comments, but by posting you allow Zuddies to display them on the site alongside the article.
To have one of your comments deleted, email [PRIVACY EMAIL] from the address you commented with. Our Privacy Policy explains what we collect when you comment and how long we keep it.
Changes to these guidelines
We may update these guidelines as the community grows. The latest version is always on this page.